10 Horrible Tales of Murder, Monsters, and Witchcraft in Iceland

Introduction

So, the chances are you’ve stumbled across this blog after discovering Iceland does, in fact, have a dark history, and you’re curious to learn a little more about it. If so, you’ve come to the right place.

In this blog, I’ll walk you through some of Iceland’s troubling tales and legends of old – welcoming you to a journey through the darker side of Iceland’s history.

Iceland is known for its breathtaking landscapes and serene beauty, but beneath that picturesque surface lies a world of eerie legends and spine-chilling tales.

Whether you’re a history buff, a supernatural enthusiast, or just looking for something intriguing to read by the fire, you’re in for a treat. So, let’s dive into the grim and fascinating stories that have shaped Icelandic folklore (and, yes, I’m sure at some point they will become a great Netflix series).

An Overview of Iceland’s Dark History

A cluster of rune stones in Iceland on a wooden log

Iceland’s history is rich with tales that blur the lines between reality and myth. For centuries, the island’s isolated and harsh environment has fostered a culture of storytelling where the supernatural and the everyday intertwine seamlessly.

These stories are more than just entertainment; they reflect the fears, values, and beliefs of Iceland’s people through the ages. From ghostly apparitions to ruthless outlaws, the dark history of Iceland is as compelling as its stunning natural beauty.

The Various Execution Sites of Iceland

Throughout Iceland’s history, justice was often as harsh as the landscape. Execution sites scattered across the country serve as grim reminders of the brutal methods used to deal with criminals and outcasts.

These sites are not just historical footnotes; they are integral to the stories of crime and punishment that have become part of Icelandic folklore.

Þingvellir National Park

Thingvellir National Park in Iceland under a blue sky and sunny day

Þingvellir, the site of Iceland’s first parliament, is not only a place of immense natural beauty but also one of historical significance. It was here that major decisions were made, and justice was often carried out, sometimes with brutal finality.

Skálholt

Photo Credit: Leon Petrosyan via Wikimedia C.C.

Skálholt is another site with a dark past, known for its religious and judicial history. This area saw its share of grim events, from witch trials to public executions.

10 Horrible Tales of Murder, Monsters, and Witchcraft in Iceland

1. Þjófafoss (Thief’s Fall)

Photo Credit: Grunkhead via Wikimedia C.C.

Nestled in the Þjórsárdalur Valley, Þjófafoss, or Thief’s Fall, is a stunning waterfall with a dark past. According to legend, this was the execution site for thieves. They were pushed off the cliffs into the roaring waters below, serving as a stark warning to others.

Today, it’s a beautiful yet eerie spot, where the serene landscape belies the brutal history that took place here. The waterfall’s powerful cascade mirrors the fear that must have gripped those led to their doom.

The story goes that the thieves, often bound and blindfolded, were led to the edge of the cliffs. With one final push, they would plunge into the icy waters below, their screams drowned out by the thunderous roar of the waterfall.

The bodies were often carried away by the swift current, disappearing into the depths of the river. This method of execution was not only a punishment but also a deterrent, warning others of the severe consequences of theft in this harsh land.

2. Drekkingarhylur (Drowning Pool) at Þingvellir

Photo Credit: Olga Ernst via Wikimedia C.C.

Þingvellir National Park is not only a geological marvel but also a historical one. Drekkingarhylur, the Drowning Pool, was where women convicted of infanticide or adultery met their end. Bound and submerged in the icy waters, their tragic fates add a haunting layer to the park’s beauty.

Walking through Þingvellir, you can almost feel the weight of these somber stories. The juxtaposition of the park’s serene environment and its dark history is both fascinating and unsettling.

At Drekkingarhylur, the condemned women were bound hand and foot and placed into a small boat. They were then rowed out to the middle of the pool, where they were pushed overboard.

The cold, dark waters would quickly envelop them, their cries echoing off the cliffs until they were silenced forever. This grim practice was meant to cleanse the community of perceived moral corruption, a stark reminder of the harsh judgments of the past.

3. Witchcraft Burnings

Burning a witch at the stake in Iceland

The Westfjords region of Iceland was a hotspot for witch hunts in the 17th century. Unlike other European countries where women were primarily accused, most victims in Iceland were men. These accused sorcerers were burned alive, their ashes scattered to the winds.

Visiting the remote Westfjords, one can’t help but think of these dark times and the fear that must have gripped the community. The isolation of this region only amplifies the eerie atmosphere, making it a poignant place to reflect on this dark chapter in history.

One of the most infamous cases involved Jón Rögnvaldsson, who was accused of using magic to cause the death of livestock. After a trial filled with fear and superstition, Jón was condemned to be burned at the stake.

As the flames consumed him, it is said that the wind carried his ashes across the fjord, spreading the fear of witchcraft even further. The haunting legacy of these burnings is a chilling reminder of how fear can lead to unspeakable acts.

4. Axlar-Björn (Björn of the Ax)

Kirkjufell mountain in Snaefellsnes peninsula, Iceland

Axlar-Björn is Iceland’s most notorious serial killer from the 16th century. Living on the Snæfellsnes Peninsula, Björn murdered numerous travelers and disposed of their bodies in gruesome ways.

His farmstead became a place of dread, and his legend lives on as one of the darkest chapters in Icelandic history.

Exploring Snæfellsnes, it’s hard to escape the chilling tales of Björn’s reign of terror. The peninsula’s rugged beauty stands in stark contrast to the gruesome acts that took place there.

Björn’s method of operation was particularly brutal. He would invite weary travelers into his home, offering them food and shelter. Once they were asleep, he would attack, often using an ax to dispatch his victims.

The bodies were buried in shallow graves around his farm or disposed of in nearby rivers. Björn’s crimes went undetected for years, with local suspicions only aroused by the increasing number of disappearances.

Eventually, his heinous acts were discovered, and he was executed in a manner befitting his crimes.

5. The Tale of Grettir the Strong (Grettis Saga)

A troll from the legend of Grettir the Strong tales

Grettir Ásmundarson, the hero of Grettis Saga, is both a historical figure and a legendary outlaw. His life was marked by battles against both human foes and supernatural creatures.

His strength and resilience are legendary, but his story is also one of isolation and tragedy. Tracing Grettir’s journey through Iceland offers a fascinating glimpse into the country’s medieval past. The saga is a captivating mix of history and legend, making Grettir one of Iceland’s most enduring figures.

Grettir’s tale is filled with dramatic encounters. From fighting trolls in the mountains to facing the dreaded draugr (undead), his exploits are the stuff of legend.

Despite his strength, Grettir’s life was one of hardship and exile. Condemned to live as an outlaw, he spent much of his life in hiding, moving from one remote location to another.

His death was as dramatic as his life, with Grettir falling victim to a treacherous plot. Even in death, his legacy continued, with tales of his strength and courage passed down through generations.

6. The Murder at Öxarárfoss

Öxarárfoss waterfall in Iceland under a blue sky

Öxarárfoss, another stunning waterfall in Þingvellir, was an execution site where men were beheaded and their bodies disposed of in the falls. The serene beauty of the waterfall masks the brutal justice that was meted out here.

Standing at Öxarárfoss, it’s hard not to imagine the final moments of those who met their fate in its waters. The sound of the cascading water seems to echo the cries of the condemned, adding a haunting resonance to this picturesque location.

The condemned men were led to the edge of the falls, where a block and ax awaited them. With a swift stroke, their heads were severed, and their bodies thrown into the turbulent waters below.

The falls would quickly wash away the remains, leaving little trace of the grim deeds. This method of execution was not only a means of dispensing justice but also served as a powerful deterrent to others.

7. The Ghost of Gunna

Photo Credit: Jakub Hałun via Wikimedia C.C.

Reykjanes Peninsula is home to the ghost of Gunna, a woman who died under mysterious circumstances and returned to haunt the living. Gunna’s restless spirit is said to cause havoc, and her story is a popular ghost tale in Icelandic folklore.

Exploring Reykjanes, you might just feel a chill in the air, as if Gunna herself is watching. The rugged landscape of Reykjanes, with its geothermal activity and stark beauty, provides the perfect backdrop for Gunna’s eerie tale.

Gunna’s story begins with her being unjustly evicted from her home by a greedy landlord. Left to fend for herself in the harsh Icelandic wilderness, she soon succumbed to the elements.

But death was not the end for Gunna. Her spirit returned with a vengeance, haunting the landlord and anyone who crossed her path.

Her ghost was said to appear as a wraith-like figure, capable of causing physical harm and terrifying those who encountered her. The locals eventually performed rituals to lay her spirit to rest, but tales of her ghostly presence persist to this day.

8. The Ghost of Skotta

The ghost of Skotta in Iceland

Skotta, the ghost of a woman who committed suicide, is said to haunt the area around Skálholt. Her spirit is believed to bring misfortune to those who encounter her.

Skotta’s tale is a poignant reminder of the sadness and despair that can linger long after death.

Visiting Skálholt, you can almost sense Skotta’s presence, adding an eerie element to this historic site. The combination of historical significance and ghostly lore makes Skálholt a compelling destination.

9. The Tale of Hildur and the Trolls

The aurora borealis at night over the incredible Icelandic snow-covered mountains and fjord

Hildur was a young woman kidnapped by trolls, only to later outsmart them and reveal their hidden treasure. Her tale is a blend of bravery, cunning, and the supernatural.

The Icelandic landscape, with its rugged terrain and hidden caves, makes it easy to believe that such creatures could exist.

Hiking through these areas, you might find yourself looking over your shoulder for trolls. Hildur’s story adds a touch of magic to the natural beauty of Iceland, making every hike an adventure.

10. The Draugr (Ghost) Legends

The black church of Búðir in Iceland's Snæfellsnes peninsula

Draugr, the Icelandic undead, are said to rise from their graves to haunt the living. These revenants are not just ghosts but physical entities capable of immense harm.

Stories of Draugr are scattered throughout Icelandic folklore, each more terrifying than the last. Exploring old cemeteries and remote landscapes, the legends of Draugr come to life, making your spine tingle.

The idea of these malevolent spirits wandering the land adds a thrilling edge to any exploration of Iceland’s historical sites.

Where Can I Check Out Some of the Locations of These Tales in Iceland?

The Northern Lights dancing above Kirkjufell mountain covered in snow, Iceland

Iceland is a treasure trove of historical sites and natural wonders that are tied to these dark tales. Here are a few spots you shouldn’t miss:

Þjórsárdalur Valley: Visit Þjófafoss and imagine the chilling executions that took place here. The valley’s natural beauty and eerie history make it a compelling destination.

Þingvellir National Park: Walk through the park and explore Drekkingarhylur and Öxarárfoss, feeling the weight of history in every step. The park’s stunning scenery and rich history make it a must-visit.

Westfjords: Learn about the witchcraft burnings and explore the remote beauty of this region. The isolation and rugged landscape add to the haunting atmosphere.

Snæfellsnes Peninsula: Trace the footsteps of Axlar-Björn and soak in the eerie atmosphere of his former haunts. The peninsula’s dramatic scenery provides a striking contrast to its dark history.

Reykjanes Peninsula: Discover the ghost of Gunna and the mysterious tales that shroud this rugged landscape. The geothermal activity and stark beauty make Reykjanes a fascinating place to explore.

Skálholt: Visit this historic site and feel the presence of Skotta as you explore its ancient buildings. The combination of historical significance and ghostly lore makes Skálholt a compelling destination.

Hiking Trails: Embark on hikes that take you through troll territories and places known for Draugr sightings. The natural beauty and supernatural tales make hiking in Iceland an unforgettable experience.

The History of Witchcraft and Sorcery in Iceland

Witchcraft in Iceland symbolised by a series of tarot cards

Witchcraft in Iceland is a fascinating and dark chapter in its history. Unlike the female-centric witch hunts of mainland Europe, Iceland’s witch hunts primarily targeted men.

This divergence offers a unique perspective on how different cultures approached the supernatural. The fear of sorcery and the unknown led to brutal trials and executions, often based on scant evidence and superstition.

The Witch Trials in Iceland

Fire at the witch trials in Iceland during the 17th century

The witch trials in Iceland, especially during the 17th century, were intense and terrifying. Accusations of witchcraft often stemmed from personal vendettas or unexplained misfortunes.

Those accused faced horrific fates, with trials leading to executions by burning. These events highlight the dark side of human nature and the lengths to which fear can drive societies.

Where Can I Learn More About These Tales?

Photo Credit: Mx. Granger via Wikimedia C.C.

For those eager to delve deeper into Iceland’s dark history, there are several resources and places to explore:

National Museum of Iceland

Located in Reykjavík, this museum offers comprehensive exhibits on Iceland’s history, including its darker aspects. It’s a great place to start your journey into Icelandic folklore and history.

The Witchcraft and Sorcery Museum

Found in Hólmavík in the Westfjords, this museum is dedicated to Icelandic witchcraft and offers a deep dive into the fear and fascination surrounding it. The exhibits provide a detailed look at the history and legends of witchcraft in Iceland.

Saga Museum

Also in Reykjavík, this museum brings to life the sagas and legends of Iceland, including tales of outlaws, ghosts, and supernatural beings. The lifelike exhibits make the stories come alive, providing a captivating experience.

Local Libraries and Bookstores

Explore Icelandic literature and historical texts that recount these chilling stories in detail. Many local libraries and bookstores have collections of Icelandic folklore and history, making it easy to continue your exploration.

Conclusion

A man standing in the snow by the woods in Iceland staring into the forest spookily

So, there you have it—a journey through some of Iceland’s most horrifying and fascinating tales. Whether you’re visiting the sites themselves or reading about them from the cozy comfort of the Panorama Glass Lodge, these stories add a thrilling layer to your Icelandic adventure.

The island’s dark history is as rich and captivating as its landscapes, offering endless intrigue for those brave enough to explore. So pack your bags, grab a good book (or ten), and get ready to uncover the secrets of Iceland’s eerie past.

Enjoy a Night Under the Stars

Last minute offer!

Stay 2 nights
in August

30%OFF

with code

SUMMEROFFER

valid only for 2-night stays
until August 31st 2025.

25%OFF

with code

BLACKSUMMER

valid only for stays between April 24 – August 10, 2025.